In some societies, the crime rate committed by teenagers is increasing. Thus, the people believe that they should receive punishments like adults. According to you what are the disadvantages of it?
Sample Answer:
In recent years, there has been a growing concern about the increasing crime rate committed by teenagers in some societies. As a result, there is a belief among the public that teenagers should receive punishments similar to those given to adults. However, this approach has several disadvantages that need to be considered.
Firstly, treating teenagers as adults in the criminal justice system fails to take into account the unique developmental stage that they are in. Adolescence is a time of significant growth and change, both physically and psychologically. Teenagers are still in the process of forming their identities and learning to make responsible decisions. Therefore, subjecting them to the same punishments as adults does not consider their capacity for rehabilitation and reformation.
Furthermore, imposing adult punishments on teenagers can have long-lasting negative effects on their future prospects. A criminal record can severely limit their opportunities for employment, education, and housing. This can perpetuate a cycle of crime and poverty, as teenagers who are unable to reintegrate into society may turn to further criminal activities as a means of survival.
Moreover, the use of adult punishments for teenagers fails to address the underlying causes of their criminal behavior. Many teenagers who engage in criminal activities come from disadvantaged backgrounds and may have experienced trauma or abuse. Instead of punitive measures, there is a need for greater investment in support services, such as counseling, education, and mentorship, to address the root causes of their behavior and prevent reoffending.
In conclusion, treating teenagers as adults in the criminal justice system has several disadvantages. It fails to consider their developmental stage, limits their future prospects, and does not address the underlying causes of their criminal behavior. Instead, a more holistic and rehabilitative approach is needed to support teenagers and help them become productive members of society.